View Single Post
  #10  
Old February 12th, 2008, 02:20 PM
kate58's Avatar
kate58 kate58 is offline
ADBB Advocate

Atkins Phase: OWL Rung 6
 
Join Date: Sep 07, 2007
Location: Ireland
Posts: 862
Rep Power: 35
kate58 has a reputation beyond reputekate58 has a reputation beyond reputekate58 has a reputation beyond reputekate58 has a reputation beyond reputekate58 has a reputation beyond reputekate58 has a reputation beyond reputekate58 has a reputation beyond reputekate58 has a reputation beyond reputekate58 has a reputation beyond reputekate58 has a reputation beyond reputekate58 has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: What if it has all been a big fat lie?

I am currently rereading this book, and more slowly. It was so stunning and so mind altering the first time that I kept rushing forward to the next bits before thinking over what I read, this time I am going slow and thinking more as I read.

I really, really urge people to read it. It won't just change what you think about eating and nutrition, but about health generally and it will also make you look very carefully at anything that is put forward as 'fact' by so-called experts.

Two of the most revealing and fascinating (if also somewhat scary) things it shows are how people who are very expert and very close to a topic can so often fail to see the woods for the trees, and how the experts who are called upon to make pronouncements and decisions which have a far reaching effect on society often are not that expert at all and/or are pushing agendas.

The world of science is very political, full of clicques and inner circles and people who are terribly protective of their own patches. They don't always have the greater good at the forefront of their minds.

I honestly believe that every doctor, no matter what their discipline, and every person who is involved in creating or contributing to health policy formulation should be MADE to read this book. Whether they agree with it's central thesis or not is almost irrelevant - it might at least encourage them to approach their decision making in a more open minded fashion.
__________________
Kate




F, 50, 5'5 Start: Sept 5th 2007
Start Weight: 255
MG1: 238 Sept 23rd
MG2: 224 Oct 23rd
MG3: 210 Dec 3rd
MG4: 196 Jan 26th
MG5: 182
My Journal






"Everyone is entitled to an informed opinion."